As the 2024/25 Premier League season unfolds, each team's strengths and weaknesses are becoming increasingly apparent. While some players have risen to the challenge, others have struggled to make an impact. In this article, we'll examine every Premier League club's worst player so far this season, from surprise underperformers to expected strugglers."
Players who have played eight or more games, including at least one start, are eligible to be included.
Brighton: Evan Ferguson [6.18]
At this time last year, Ferguson was the greatest thing ever and was expected to be transferred for £100 million. He is now available for loan in January and can hardly get a kick. This season, he has made ten substitute appearances and two starts in the Premier League, scoring one goal. It's possible that people became overly enthusiastic about him.
Aston Villa: Jaden Philogene [5.92]
Aston Villa's Jaden Philogene has been a major disappointment this season, earning a dismal rating of 5.92. The young winger's lack of end product, poor decision-making, and inconsistent work rate have hindered Villa's attacking momentum. Philogene's struggles to beat defenders, create scoring opportunities, and provide width have raised concerns about his readiness for Premier League football.
Bournemouth: Julian Araujo [6.11]
Following a rather lackluster loan stint at Las Palmas last season, Araujo has not adjusted to life in the Premier League. Figure it out. He can't protect himself because he has been hurt for a long time.
Chelsea: Christopher Nkunku [6.33]
Since joining Chelsea, Nkunku has failed to live up to the hype. He was one of the top goal scorers in Europe when he left RB Leipzig, but he suffered a severe injury prior to his competitive debut. Although he has only scored five goals in the Premier League since his debut, he has seldom ever started.
Ipswich: Jens Cajuste [6.22]
Ipswich's Jens Cajuste has been a disappointment this season, earning a rating of 6.22. The Swedish midfielder's struggles to control the tempo of the game, create scoring opportunities, and track back defensively have hindered Ipswich's progress. Cajuste's lack of vision, poor passing range, and indecisiveness have made him a liability in the Tractor Boys' midfield.
Liverpool: Joe Gomez [6.56]
Liverpool's Joe Gomez has endured a torrid season, meriting a rating of 6.56. The English defender's form has plummeted, with costly errors and lackluster displays undermining the Reds' backline. Gomez's struggles with positioning, aerial duels, and decision-making have exposed Liverpool to opposition counter-attacks, making him the team's worst performer this season.
Everton: Beto [6.18]
Beto has been a major letdown for Everton this season, earning a rating of 6.18. The Portuguese forward has struggled to adapt to the Premier League, scoring just two goals and providing one assist in 15 appearances. His poor shot conversion rate (10%) and mediocre passing accuracy (70%) have hindered Everton's attacking potency. Unless Beto improves significantly, his future at Goodison Park looks uncertain.
Arsenal: Jakub Kiwior [6.23]
Arsenal's Jakub Kiwior has struggled to impress this season, earning a rating of 6.23. The Polish defender's inexperience and lack of composure have led to costly errors, compromising the Gunners' backline. Kiwior's difficulties in reading the game, winning aerial battles, and distributing the ball effectively have raised concerns about his suitability for Arsenal's title-chasing squad.
Crystal Palace: Nathaniel Clyne [6.03]
Crystal Palace's Nathaniel Clyne has endured a dismal season, earning a rating of 6.03. The experienced right-back's decline has been stark, with his defensive vulnerabilities and lack of attacking prowess exposing the Eagles' flank. Clyne's struggles to cope with pacey wingers, combined with his limited contribution in the final third, have made him a liability for Patrick Vieira's side.
Newcastle: Joe Willock [6.29]
Newcastle's Joe Willock has been a major disappointment this season, earning a rating of 6.29. The midfielder's lack of creativity, inconsistent work rate, and failure to contribute goals or assists have hindered the Magpies' attacking momentum. Willock's struggles to impose himself on games and make a meaningful impact have raised questions about his long-term future at St. James' Park.
He only has 1 goal involvement, it would be hard for him to be back in Newcastle starting xl, where Sandro Tonali, Joelinton and Bruno Guimaraes are shining.
Southampton: Jack Stephens [5.93]
Southampton's Jack Stephens has been a liability this season, earning a dismal rating of 5.93. The center-back's catastrophic performances have been marred by clumsy errors, poor positioning, and a lack of aerial dominance. Stephens' struggles to cope with physical strikers and his propensity for conceding costly penalties have made him a weak link in the Saints' fragile defense.
West Ham: Vladimir Coufal [6.16]
West Ham's Vladimir Coufal has endured a woeful season, earning a rating of 6.16. The Czech right-back's usually reliable defensive skills have deserted him, with Coufal struggling to contain opposition wingers and making a string of costly errors. His attacking contributions have also dried up, leaving the Hammers' right flank exposed and ineffective.
Tottenham: Archie Gray [6.20]
Tottenham's Archie Gray has been a disappointment this season, earning a rating of 6.20. Despite his highly touted potential, the young midfielder has struggled to make an impact, often appearing overwhelmed by the pace and physicality of the Premier League. Gray's indecisiveness, lack of creativity, and misplaced passes have hindered Tottenham's attacking flow, raising concerns about his readiness for top-flight football.
Wolves: Carlos Forbs [6.08]
Wolves' Carlos Forbs has been a letdown this season, earning a rating of 6.08. The defender's struggles to fill the void left by Craig Dawson have been evident, with Forbs often caught out of position and making costly errors. His lack of aerial dominance, slow reactions, and poor decision-making have compromised Wolves' defensive solidity, making him the team's worst performer this season.
Man Utd: Mason Mount [6.08]
Manchester United's Mason Mount has been a major disappointment this season, earning a rating of 6.08. The highly touted midfielder has failed to replicate his Chelsea form, struggling to create scoring opportunities, dictate the tempo, and provide defensive cover. Mount's inconsistency, lack of vision, and misplaced passes have hindered United's attacking momentum, making him the team's worst performer this season.
Nottingham Forest: Taiwo Awoniyi [6.06]
Nottingham Forest's Taiwo Awoniyi has endured a nightmare season, earning a dismal rating of 6.06. The Nigerian striker's struggles to find the back of the net have been alarming, with Awoniyi lacking the clinical finishing and intelligent movement required to trouble Premier League defenders. His inability to hold up the ball, create chances for others, and provide a focal point in attack has severely hindered Forest's attacking potency.
Man City: Kyle Walker [6.29]
Manchester City's Kyle Walker has been a disappointment this season, earning a rating of 6.29. The experienced right-back's decline has been stark, with Walker struggling to cope with the pace and agility of opposing wingers. His defensive positioning has been suspect, and his usual attacking threat has been nonexistent, leaving City vulnerable on the counter and lacking width in attack.
Wolves: Carlos Forbs [6.08]
Wolves' Carlos Forbs has been a letdown this season, earning a rating of 6.08. His defensive struggles have been a major concern, with Forbs frequently caught out of position and making costly errors. His inability to win aerial battles and lack of composure under pressure have compromised Wolves' defensive solidity, making him the team's worst performer this season.
Brentford: Fabio Carvalho [6.23]
Brentford's Fabio Carvalho has lost his luster this season, earning a rating of 6.23. The Portuguese midfielder's creativity and flair, which once thrilled Bees fans, have given way to inconsistency and indecision. Carvalho's struggles to control the tempo, create scoring chances, and provide defensive cover have hindered Brentford's attacking potency and raised concerns about his long-term impact.